1 great , 2 good, 1 ok. I rate Azure Sands 5 star, hands down the best of the 4 pack, it fills the whole house with a warm, gender-neutral scent. Was disappointed in the Vintage Oak (3 stars), it smells great, but extremely faint and almost have to have your face 12" from the burning candle to smell it. The Sea Salt/ Ginger (4 stars) is used in my home office, it's light and fresh and doesn't overwhelm the room while I'm on the computer. Bamboo Waters (4 stars) is great in our guest bedroom. We've had friends and family love the scent. It's too feminine for me (and the Manly Indulgence label IMO), but have to give it good rating as others love it. All-in-all a good collection for the money!